News

Marcellus Williams, set for execution, says DNA wasn’t on knife used

Published

3 weeks ago

September 25, 2024

Marcellus Williams, set for execution, says DNA wasn't on knife used

A Missouri demise row inmate set to be executed Tuesday within the 1998 deadly stabbing of a former reporter maintains his innocence and that he is by no means been forensically linked to the killing.

Marcellus Williams, 55, is about to develop into the third inmate executed in Missouri this yr and the fifteenth or sixteenth within the nation, relying on whether or not he is declared useless earlier than or after Travis James Mullis, one other inmate set for execution in Texas on the identical day. Two extra back-to-back executions in Alabama and Oklahoma on Thursday.

Williams was convicted of murdering Lisha Gayle, a former reporter for the St. Louis Publish-Dispatch fatally stabbed throughout a housebreaking within the dwelling she shared together with her husband.

The St. Louis County Prosecutor’s Workplace helps Williams’ claims of innocence and not too long ago filed a movement to vacate his conviction − a transfer accepted by a county trial choose, however rapidly contested by Missouri Legal professional Common Andrew Bailey. The case was tossed again to the identical choose for a listening to, and on Sept. 12, he reversed his determination.

On Monday, Sept. 23, Missouri Governor Mike Parson, a Republican, and the Missouri Supreme Court docket denied clemency to Williams, and his execution will go on as deliberate, based on the Innocence Challenge.

In the meantime those that imagine Williams is harmless proceed to battle for a reprieve.

As Williams execution approaches, USA TODAY talked to his attorneys and is trying again on the crime and who the person is.

Extra about what Marcellus Williams was convicted of

On the morning of Aug. 11, 1998, Gayle was within the bathe when police mentioned Williams broke into her dwelling on a personal gated road.

The 42-year-old girl left the second-floor toilet and was strolling downstairs when police say she encountered Williams on the touchdown. In some unspecified time in the future, she was stabbed 43 occasions with a kitchen knife from the house.

Later that evening, Gayle’s husband, Daniel Picus, discovered his spouse’s physique and known as 911. Among the many proof police collected: bloody shoeprints and fingerprints, a knife sheath and the suspect’s hair collected from Gayle’s shirt, fingers and the ground. Lacking from the home have been Gayle’s purse and jacket, and her husband’s laptop computer.

A suspect was not instantly named so in Might 1999, Gayle’s household introduced a $10,000 reward for data resulting in an arrest and conviction within the case.

Not lengthy after an inmate named Henry Cole and Williams’ girlfriend, Lara Asaro, named Williams because the perpetrator. On the time of his conviction, Williams had simply began serving a 20-year jail sentence for robbing a downtown St. Louis donut store.

No forensic proof tied Williams to the crime scene however a jury convicted him of homicide and housebreaking.

Williams’ attorneys have argued that each informants stood to learn from their cooperation with prosecutors, and that their tales typically modified or conflicted with different particulars in regards to the killing. Each witnesses have since died.

Tales of justice and motion throughout America: Join USA TODAY’s That is America e-newsletter.

Extra about who Williams is

Born in South Bend, Indiana, on Dec. 30, 1968, Williams, his mom and two brothers moved to St. Louis when he was about 5.

Williams grew up in an impoverished and dysfunctional family the place he was uncovered to alcohol, medicine, weapons at a younger age, based on courtroom information. He was subjected to violent sexual and bodily abuse by some members of the family, deserted by his mother and father, and his household condoned legal habits and substance abuse, the information say.

The demise of Williams’ older brother in 1997 deeply bothered him, since his brother had been a father determine to him, courtroom information present. That very same yr, Williams burglarized a house, and spent a stint in jail earlier than his 1998 conviction for robbing the donut shot.

Williams’ attorneys introduced proof that he was “a caring and loving father” through the penalty part of his homicide trial.

A number of of Williams’s members of the family and associates, together with his son and his step-daughter, testified about Williams’s constructive relationship with the youngsters and mentioned that his execution “would have a big impact on his household.”

Whereas in jail, Williams has devoted a lot of his time to learning Islam and writing poetry, based on the Innocence Challenge.

Williams was beforehand set to be executed twice, however each have been halted

Williams was set to be executed in January 2015 and in August 2017.

Each deadly injections have been halted to conduct additional DNA testing and investigation. The latest keep of execution was ordered by then-Gov. Eric Greiten who appointed a board of inquiry to look into the case.

However through the summer time of 2023, newly sworn-in Gov. Mike Parson dissolved the board and lifted the keep. The courtroom, Parsons mentioned, would resolve Williams’ destiny and the Missouri Supreme Court docket issued a 3rd execution warrant for Williams.

What has Williams argued in his appeals?

In January, Williams’ attorneys filed a movement to vacate his conviction and sentence.

On Aug. 21, county prosecuting legal professional Wesley Bell’s workplace and Williams’ attorneys reached an settlement permitting Williams to enter a brand new, no-contest plea to first-degree homicide in change for all times in jail sentence with out parole. The sufferer’s husband, Daniel Picus, signed off on the plea.

Though Bell moved to overturn Williams’ homicide conviction, state Legal professional Common Andrew Bailey argued it ought to stand and ordered St. Louis County Circuit Choose Bruce Hilton − who accepted the plea − to carry an evidentiary listening to on the matter.

The protection, Bailey mentioned, “created a false narrative of innocence in an effort to get a convicted assassin off of demise row and fulfill their political ends.”

Throughout the Aug. 28 listening to, the retired prosecutor who dealt with the case admitted proof was mishandled within the 1998 trial that would have exonerated Williams.

However on Sept. 12, Hilton declined to vacate Williams’ conviction and sentence, regardless of questions on DNA proof on the knife used within the assault. In appeals, his protection group produced proof that DNA taken from the knife revealed an unknown male profile and didn’t match Williams.

“There is no such thing as a foundation for a courtroom to seek out that Williams is harmless, and no courtroom has made such a discovering,” St. Louis County Circuit Choose Bruce Hilton wrote. “Williams is responsible of first-degree homicide, and has been sentenced to demise.”

Williams’ legal professional Tricia Rojo Bushnell, informed USA TODAY her shopper’s protection group will file extra appeals and search clemency.

Except the courts or the governor intervene, Williams’ execution stays set this week.

Williams is one among 5 males being executed in lower than per week

Williams is one among 5 males anticipated to be executed within the U.S. in a six-day interval. First was Freddie Owens, who was executed on Friday in South Carolina amid contemporary doubts over his guilt.

On Tuesday, concurrently Williams’ execution, Texas is about to execute Travis James Mullis within the homicide of his toddler son.

After Tuesday’s double execution, Thursday is anticipated to carry two extra back-to-back executions. Alabama is about to make use of nitrogen gasoline to execute Alan Eugene Miller within the taking pictures deaths of three co-workers in 1999 regardless of proof of his psychological sickness and a witness to the state’s earlier nitrogen gasoline execution in January who described the tactic as “horrific.”