Has Narendra Modi lost his mojo?

Pity India’s pollsters. They’ve by no means been a lot good at predicting election outcomes. In June, they suffered a humiliating setback when India’s ruling Bharatiya Janata Occasion (BJP) unexpectedly misplaced its majority in a basic election. Pradeep Gupta, the top of Axis My India company, was so upset that he burst into tears on reside tv.

Promising to do higher, pollsters quickly turned their consideration to the primary two regional elections of Narendra Modi’s third time period. (India’s prime minister pulled collectively a coalition authorities.) Their exit polls largely predicted a crushing defeat for the BJP within the northern state of Haryana and a hung parliament within the union territory of Jammu & Kashmir. When outcomes have been introduced on October eighth, the pollsters have been confounded once more: the BJP received simply in Haryana and an opposition alliance gained a majority in Jammu & Kashmir.

There are three conclusions to be drawn—other than the truth that Indian elections are laborious to foretell. First, the BJP electoral machine seems to have discovered its toes once more, regardless of Mr Modi’s weakened mandate. His new authorities has struggled to adapt to unfamiliar stress from allies, opposition events, courts and activists. It has additionally confronted a rift with the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), the Hindu nationalist motion from which it grew.

The BJP confronted further challenges in Haryana, a largely agricultural state the place it has been in energy since 2014. Many farmers there apprehensive that Mr Modi may reintroduce agricultural reform legal guidelines that he was pressured to repeal in 2021 after huge protests. The occasion’s popularity additionally took successful in 2023 when a number of feminine wrestlers from the state accused a BJP legislator of sexual harassment. Within the basic election, the BJP received solely 5 out of ten seats in Haryana, half its tally in 2019.

But, within the state ballot, the BJP took 48 of 90 native meeting seats. A decisive issue was the RSS. It took a back-seat function within the basic election due to disagreements with BJP leaders. However the group launched a farmers’ outreach scheme in Haryana in September, deploying 150 volunteers to every district. It additionally helped that the BJP determined to nominate a brand new chief minister from a mid-tier caste in March and to decide on dozens of recent candidates.

A second conclusion is that the Congress occasion, the BJP’s essential nationwide rival, has a lot work to do. Congress received half the seats in Haryana within the basic election, however solely 37 of 90 within the state ballot. Occasion insiders blamed complacency in its management, a dearth of recent blood amongst candidates and over-reliance on a neighborhood occasion chieftain from the upper-caste Jat group. That alienated many lower-caste voters. Congress additionally failed to barter a seat-sharing pact with considered one of its personal companions in an opposition alliance.

The BJP could also be heartened, too, by its efficiency relative to Congress in Jammu & Kashmir. Opposition leaders portrayed the consequence as an indictment of Mr Modi’s transfer to strip the largely Muslim area of its semi-autonomy in 2019. The consequence will little doubt enhance stress on Mr Modi to revive its statehood. But the BJP nonetheless received 29 of 90 seats (all in largely Hindu Jammu). Congress received simply six; its accomplice, the Nationwide Convention, took 42. BJP leaders cite that as additional proof that, in a straight struggle, they simply outgun Congress. In addition they argue that the election’s peaceable conduct proves that Mr Modi has introduced stability to the area.

But, cheery as this may all appear for the BJP, it’s much less so for Mr Modi. A 3rd conclusion is that his occasion seems to be rising much less depending on him to win votes. In Haryana, he held simply 4 rallies in the course of the election marketing campaign, in contrast with ten in 2014 and 6 in 2019. In Jammu & Kashmir, he held 4. And BJP candidates in each polls centered extra on native points than on his picture as a muscular, infallible chief. That would spell bother for him if rivals within the BJP launch a management bid sooner or later.

The massive query now’s how the outcomes will have an effect on the subsequent state elections, particularly one in Maharashtra due by November twenty sixth. Regional components will most likely dominate there, too, however the outcomes from Haryana and Jammu & Kashmir might strengthen the BJP’s hand in seat-sharing talks with coalition companions whereas weakening Congress’s bargaining energy. The result in Maharashtra will decide whether or not the BJP can consolidate its obvious comeback from the general-election upset. The race can be tight, in accordance with polls. However don’t wager on it. ■

Subscribers to The Economist can signal as much as our new Opinion publication, which brings collectively the most effective of our leaders, columns, visitor essays and reader correspondence.